Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
Natural or Induced?
Log In to post a reply

121 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
thesweetcheat
thesweetcheat
6214 posts

Re: Natural or Induced?
Aug 27, 2012, 18:04
tjj wrote:
postman wrote:
The winter solstice doesn't show that winter is waning, i'd have said the opposite, that winter is about to kick in properly.
I don't see why our beliefs couldn't have filtered into they're belief systems, our stone erecting culture predates dynastic Egypt by as much as a thousand years.

I think that it is in built, A 2005 survey published in Encyclopedia Britannica found that the non-religious made up about 11.9% of the world's population, and atheists only about 2.3%. So it would seem that atheism is the aberrant behavior, if that many people believe in something greater than themselves it must prove something. Either that there is something or we are massively deluding ourselves for no real purpose.

Those people who entered cathedrals and were led into believing what they were told, might have already had an inkling that the world is stranger than it seems, they had questions, they had experiences, they turned to those who said they were in the know, but then got pulled away into the wrong direction. There might be something to religion, but it will only ever be someones interpretation of that something. All religions are right and wrong.

I have no leanings towards any one religion, I am not religious, but I will defend to the hilt for the right of god/s and the after life to exist.


Thoughtful words Postman .. what I meant to say about the winter solstice was that it celebrates the 'return of the light' - sure it can get very much colder before it gets warmer but does start to get gradually lighter. The dynastic Egyptians believed their Pharaohs (and close families) would go into the Afterlife but I do wonder what the 'afterlife' status was for the many slaves. Probably zero.

Atheism is by and large a product of science and to believe in anything else is said to be delusion. And yet anyone who is grieving for a dead loved one cannot help but hang onto a thread that something of them still exists somewhere.


Nicely put, both of you. June, you made a very perceptive point in the excised bit of this thread about the fact that people don't want to accept that "this is it". I think that's entirely right.
Topic Outline:

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index