Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
local tv: metal detectorists vs archaeologists
This topic is locked

207 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
slumpystones
769 posts

Re: Afore ye go....
Jun 03, 2007, 21:37
kevmar wrote:
You arn't being fair,
I consider it an insult accusing me of that,
even your Mr Swift knows my views
about our anchient stones,historic places,
My detecting hobby has nothing to do with this,
I do care about these places,always have always will.
Don't try to judge me
after all you don't know me,
and you're picking up on my past run ins with
a certain pair.
Regards,
Kevmar.


Actually I have absolutely no knowledge of anything prior to reading this ancient thread yesterday, so I have to make my assumptions based on what I read here. It all seems very plain to me. If it can be picked up, carried off and stashed away, it's being saved "for the nation". If it's too heavy to move then it should be protected "for the nation".

The big difference is that in the first case "the nation" won't get any benefit, or in many cases, even know about the 'sterling' work being done by someone who keeps their finds to themselves.

Some 'benefit', I'm sure you'll agree.

To use the smokescreen of protecting ancient monuments "for the nation" while preventing "the nation" from seeing anything dug up is, quite frankly, offensive and no real contribution to the argument at all.
Topic Outline:

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index