=
×

Julian Cope presents Head Heritage

Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
For Ceremonial purposes?
Log In to post a reply
127 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
Evergreen Dazed
1881 posts

Re: For Ceremonial purposes?
Aug 16, 2013, 10:26
Sanctuary wrote:
Evergreen Dazed wrote:
As I said, I wouldn't get too hung up about it if I were you. Even if you think of something like the World Cup final there is an element of ceremony about it. I really think ceremony and ritual are words used to convey that we don't really know what was going on at these places, but whatever it was there seems to have been a formality attached to it.
When you encounter an enigmatic site like Fernworthy, for example, a graduated stone circle with rows leading off toward cairns, I think ceremony/ritual use is a perfectly acceptable description, precisely because it is so vague.


I'm not hung up on it ED, just opening a point for discussion, but would only ever consider ceremonial as a possibility amongst others myself. The point has been brought up before that proof is everything has it not?


I think there are strong indications of ceremonial/ritual activity though, I can't really see why this would be questioned?

You often hear archaeologists say a LIKELY ritual function.

If you were an archaeologist, in what other way would you describe the function & use of what you have found at prehistoric sites?

I will admit there is perhaps a feeling that an archaeologist has to come up with 'something' to justify their position and the work they have carried out (in the eyes of the public, anyway), but I think anybody involved in the subject knows it is just a kind of 'best fit' and isn't particularly important.

I'm interested - how would you describe a site like the Avebury circle(s) to the general public? If the answer to that is along the lines of 'We don't know what this was used for', that is essentially what ceremony/ritual is saying anyway. I don't think the general public is being misled by literature saying 'likely ritual function', because, to be honest, there are plenty of pointers toward its use being just that!
In reply to:
Re: For Ceremonial purposes? (Sanctuary)		 Replies:
Re: For Ceremonial purposes? (Sanctuary)
Re: For Ceremonial purposes? (jonmor)
Topic Outline:
The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index