Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
Silbury Hill »
To the Heart of the Matter
Log In to post a reply

211 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
Littlestone
Littlestone
5386 posts

Re: the spiritual beliefs of some people.
Jan 04, 2008, 15:46
moss wrote:
There is a terrible sadness that lies at the heart of all this, the damage that has been done to Silbury over the centuries out of curiosity and the need for treasure, and then the simple truth that what did lie at Silbury's heart was this small mound surrounded by stones with simple offerings.
Taking the subject away from conservation for the moment, and focussing on the spiritual aspect, I believe that archaeologists have to come to terms with a respect for the beliefs of the past. Christianity exists besides many other religious beliefs, secularism strides over christian belief, but it is still respected. Archaeologists have to accept and respect this extra religious dimension when approaching the excavation of prehistoric monuments that obviously have deep symbolic meaning in their past history.
Dean Merewether for all his faults did record what he saw, but he was a man of the church highly intrigued by 'pagan' beliefs, and hardly sympathetic towards them. The stones are part of Silbury therefore should remain inside, they would hardly make an elegant centrepiece in a museum anyway.
The damage cannot be undone and that is what so depressing, but if, as many believe, Silbury has a spiritual meaning, then at least give it back its dignity for a 'remembered' past, and a peaceful future in which there are no further intrusions.


A truly insightful post moss, and one that should stay at the top of this thread for a little while.
Topic Outline:

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index