Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
Line of sight calculator
Log In to post a reply

135 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
Sanctuary
Sanctuary
4670 posts

Re: Line of sight calculator
Dec 11, 2010, 09:01
nigelswift wrote:
Sanctuary wrote:
[What if it was only the ditch that was the important part and the bank just the spoil heap from it dumped on the outside and left, rather than spending donkeys more years removing it.


You could say the same about Silbury, that it's an irrelevant spoil heap, in fact someone did suggest it, or you could reverse the speculation and say the ditch was irrelevant, and merely the place the material was obtained from. I would have thought though, if we are to look at it in purely ergonomic terms, they wouldn't have built the wall as a spoil heap as the effort of piling it up would be much greater than spreading it out horizontally further away.


Yes there are different ways at looking at it of course. You could say it was a 'chicken and egg' situation as one produced the other simultaneously. What difference it would have made to the overall plan if either the ditch or bank were omitted would be another point to debate but I thought it was something to consider…as you would of course when researching any project.
As to Silbury possibly being a spoil heap, well it was a brilliantly constructed one if it was…which it wasn’t of course…I think!!
Topic Outline:

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index