Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
Stonehenge and its Environs »
The Secrets of Stonehenge
Log In to post a reply

71 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
tiompan
tiompan
5758 posts

Re: The Secrets of Stonehenge
Jun 02, 2009, 16:53
Gwass wrote:
Thanks for that, it's all very interesting. I'd not really heard of phenomonology in the way it is described in the link someone posted and felt it was a bit inaccessible.

However I have recently got a book called the phenomonology of landscape which I've not read yet but I understood it in an archaeological sense to refer to the sybolic way in which ancient people or otherwise encountered their landscape both in a real and spiritual sense, which I thought was exactly what the programme last night was exploring i.e. a real and imaginery line (the cursus) defining a zone of the living from a zone of the dead etc etc.

Why rivers, hills, pottery, stone axes, ditches etc were sacred rather than just functional entities in peoples minds. Not be that familiar with phenomonology I'm not sure.

Would welcome anyones thoughts.


Tilley's "P of landscape " is the classic British P archaeological text . It's probably not fair for me to say too much seeing as you have yet to read it but I found it , as well as his other P inspired books (didn't learn did I ?)
, trying to be polite , tosh . It's the ramblings of a 20 th C archaeo who has gone for a few walks in important prehistoric landscapes and allowed us an insight into how he thinks one of the earlier inhabitants of that landscape might have perceived it .As mentioned earlier people are always writing about their subjective feelings at monuments , Tilley has a greater breadth of knowledge in relation to these sites than the average punter but this does not translate into a better appreciation of Neolithic/ Bronze Age cognition , David Cameron couldn't have been less inspiring ,
Merleau -Ponty and the whole notion of embodiment is an inavluable tool but I have yet to read anything convincing in relation to archaeology . It's reminiscent of trendy vicars rapping a sermon . I hear he is a really nice bloke though .
Topic Outline:

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index