Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
Neanderthals v Humans
Log In to post a reply

137 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
Sanctuary
Sanctuary
4670 posts

Re: Neanderthals v Humans
Nov 07, 2012, 21:02
thesweetcheat wrote:
Interesting stuff LS. Of course in this country there are known Mesolithic "seasonal" camps like Starr Carr and the wetlands on the Severn shore, but nothing particularly structural as far as I know (unless you count fish traps!). Plus some caves were no doubt occupied regularly/seasonally before and after the last Ice Age.

So yeah, examples of places being used regularly even if not in the form of permanent homesteads, etc. But little to compare with the Australian stone patterns you refer to (although fro something like that to have survived 10,000 years plus would be quite an achievement, even for something constructed from stones).

I still can't help but feel that the bigger ceremonial monuments reflect an awareness of seasonal cycles that would be more relevant to people based in one place and trying to create a permanent, sustainable life from farming (grain and livestock), where celestial cycles and territorial "ownership" become more important than they would to a hunter/gatherer group that essentially follow the herd, as it were. So much is speculative, it's impossible to get a real grasp before any theory slips away into unknowns.

My own view (until better - any - evidence comes along) is that Neanderthal people could have created very simple funerary monuments (e.g. slab over grave) as we know they respected the dead from the archaeology available, but that they probably did not build any more structurally complex monuments, as such behaviour is not generally exhibited by any Hominid species - as far as we know - until a period when subsistence shifted from pure hunter/gatherer to something more settled. Could easily be wrong, obviously.


Coming in late on this and admit to knowing very little of Neanderthal life, but is there any evidence to show that they worshipped the ancestors or believed in the Afterlife? If not, then I don't suppose there was much call for monuments to house or worship the dead in was there! Although they are known to have inhabited caves and the like, they may also have constructed timber type dwellings of which there would be no record of today...presumably?
Topic Outline:

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index