Head To Head
Log In
Register
Unsung Forum »
Great Commercial Suicide Albums
Log In to post a reply

76 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
IanB
IanB
6761 posts

Edited May 12, 2011, 21:18
Re: Great Commercial Suicide Albums
May 12, 2011, 21:16
Fatalist wrote:
Funny, I've been away for a few days, but found myself pondering a similar subject - 'next biggest thing' bands that utterly failed to deliver - that led me onto a prime example a band taking a glorious wrong turn: Mansun's Six album. I wasn't a huge fan of their debut (Attack of the Grey Lantern, rubbish title) but I really liked the lead single from Six (the distinctly Police-like Being a Girl), so took a punt... Blimey, with a sound that's Pro-Tooled within an inch of its life, it swings wildly between genius and unlistenable, often within the same song, but it ain't half ambitious/odd - imagine if the Manics had done OK Computer. Topped off with this atrocity of a sleeve http://www.a-reminder.org/music/?p=2425 - like Pendragon, only worse - it's no surprise that it sank their chances of before they'd even really got going. Their third and final album was lacklustre, tail-between-the-legs wimp rock - lead single 'I Can Only Disappoint You' said it all...


I love Six. It is an absurd record but packed with tunes and ideas that range from genius to idiocy. Not sure if they were going after the Marillion / Porc Tree audience but the cover suggests as much. Whoever did it was no Mark Wilkinson though.

Still, if Radiohead had turned in a record like that after The Bends the chairs of every rock critic would have been wet with excitement but Radiohead would never have dared to risk being that uncool. I am not even sure they had the collective musical talent to make a record as ridiculous as Six. A limited arsenal can certainly help rein things in.
Topic Outline:

Unsung Forum Index