Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
Ness of Brodgar »
'MUST READ' article on the Ness of Brodgar
Log In to post a reply

25 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
CianMcLiam
CianMcLiam
1067 posts

Re: 'MUST READ' article on the Ness of Brodgar
Jan 16, 2017, 11:50
tiompan wrote:
CianMcLiam wrote:
spencer wrote:
Just to flag up the link to this posted by tomatoman over on TMA. Moss has commented that she has learnt more from it than the current series, and, since I've managed to miss the latter so far, I no longer feel lacking. A truly excellent piece, imo. Well done, Archaeology Institute of America's feature writer .. http://www.archaeology.org/issues/61-1301/features/327-scotland-orkney-neolithic-brodgar


It's a really nice piece. Thanks for the link. I still can't fathom why no archaeologist has publicly expressed the likely function of the site as a large fortification.


Maybe it could be explained ,that , like a lot of monuments it has a history ,with buildings being built over earlier buildings , others collapsing etc .The hope /expectation seems to be that the earliest monument was a chambered cairn .
The earliest dates so far are c.3512 BC (and they are still digging ) and the first enclosing wall is believed to be about 500 years later , so a fortification description is not likely to be applicable at that point . Contemporary Skara Bare and Barnhouse have nothing suggestive of of fortification and although we know the period probably had plenty of inter personal violence there is no sign of any warfare or weaponry as was obvious at some CE 'S .


I suppose you could say the same for Jericho where walls were eventually built around a settlement that had a very long history and multiple layers of construction.

In the end, the Ness had a gigantic wall and apparently an exterior ditch. The thickness of the walls are pretty extreme for a ritual or cult site.
You wouldn't need explicit signs of warfare to explain it, it would be as much about insecurity in a remote area with presumably a significant amount of wealth on the hoof. Even if the Orkney inhabitants were all peace, love and cuddliness they still have to deal with the 'other guy problem'.
Topic Outline:

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index