Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
Stonehenge »
Stone Shifting
Log In to post a reply

158 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
nigelswift
8112 posts

Re: Stone Shifting
Aug 25, 2003, 08:59
Sunday afternoon. Rocks, logs, holes in the lawn….

Gordon, hope you don’t mind all the questions. This time it’s about putting the uprights into the holes. Small scale, I had a problem with the stone not pivoting cleanly into the hole but sometimes sliding down on the pivot point, so the arc it goes through is elongated. I could design for that OK but it’s an intermittent effect, depending on how rough or uneven the stone is. As such, I was getting an unpredictable degree of inaccuracy. Any thoughts? Steve, do you have a lawn?

The only way I found to cure it on the small-scale model was to have the stone tilted upwards instead of horizontal. That way, it seems to build up a bit more rotational speed when it drops –it’s already built up a bit of speed when it reaches horizontal, and after that it seems to pivot round more cleanly and not to start sliding down the pivot point. So that might be something worth thinking about.

I suppose, if you did find tilting the stone was good, you could change your means of elevating it by building a sloping track and rowing it up until the end was supported on the A frame. At that point you could remove much of the track and end up with the stone supported in much the same way as you’re proposing, but tilted instead of level.

(If it did turn out to work that way it would have a lot of advantages apart from the pivoting aspect: you could set the whole thing up before the stone was brought to it, it would involve less mechanical effort and time, and you wouldn’t be needing the stone to be raised so high. Also, it would be sweet if your Big Idea, stone rowing, was not only the key to transporting the stones but also to erecting them.)

I tried this and it seemed to work, but I’m acutely aware that small-scale experiments may be quite different to what you’re proposing.
Topic Outline:

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index