Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
Please sign the Stonehenge petition
Log In to post a reply

18 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
jonmor
jonmor
150 posts

Re: Please sign the Stonehenge petition
Dec 04, 2014, 19:14
“The whole Stonehenge landscape has an outstanding universal value that is of immense significance for all people for all time, and this transcends any consideration of sorting out a 21st century part-time traffic jam.”


Difficult because this is obviously a forum in which people care about monuments. Not everybody thinks the above and it is a statement that can be fairly easily dismissed in an infrastructure value comparison setting.

Other people might, for instance, be more interested in sustainability. The proposed solution, using current definitions, is a far more 'sustainable' solution than the deep bore alternative. It is also cheaper.

Nevertheless, I have sympathy with the viewpoint as I believe the monument will eventually be shown to be both a landmark in our society's evolution and also relevant to today's society. This would put it into a very special category. However, road building projects can be easily completed within only one or two decades, so assuming the project goes ahead, time has almost certainly run out.

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index