Head To Head
Log In
Register
The Modern Antiquarian Forum »
Detectorists
Log In to post a reply

60 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
Sanctuary
Sanctuary
4670 posts

Re: Detectorists Petition
Feb 03, 2018, 09:13
nigelswift wrote:
Well, nighthawks are a minor problem compared with "legal" non reporting. Dr Sam Hardy estimates there are 24K legal detectorists finding (per PAS, CBA, EH, archaeologists and a detecting forum survey) circa 30 recordable artefacts per year, which is 720,000 per year whereas so far, in 20 years (per PAS), they've only shown PAS 1.3 million.

Feel free to say that's somehow wrong or exaggerated or unjust, but as Prof David Gill has said: "We have to ask by how much it would have to be "wrong" to make the figures acceptable." My answer to that is "goodness knows" and so should everyone's be.

Anyway, the only reason I got drawn into this was to point out that all the good people who use TMA who take nothing, are in no way comparable. They aren't, and I think that should be made crystal clear.


Yes Nigel -'Estimates', nothing more, and has to be grossly exaggerated because how many of those 24,000 legal detectorists were actually observed sneaking off with the goodies? A totally unrealistic figure that cannot possibly be supported! Serious concern is one thing, but please keep it realistic.
Topic Outline:

The Modern Antiquarian Forum Index