Head To Head
Log In
Register
U-Know! Forum »
Where did it all go wrong?
Log In to post a reply

3 messages
Topic View: Flat | Threaded
nigelswift
8112 posts

Re: Where did it all go wrong?
Apr 26, 2006, 07:00
Hopefully the monarchy will die with the queen.

Actually, IMO moaning about monarchy is really moaning about the impossibility of devising a satisfactory system of government.

Government might work in this country if you abolished the monarchy and didn't replace it with a presidency, but it would be dangerous to reduce the number of foci at the top as the PM would tend to take even more presidential powers and, because he also controls parliament, we'd be worse off than most other countries that have actual presidents.

I'm all for finding a royal bloodline that has better DNA in it, and getting rid of all the privilege and snobbery that it fosters, but keeping it hereditary (shock horror!) or subject to a lottery draw (which is the same thing) has a lot to be said for it. Elected presidencies or elected monarchies attract the wrong sort. We'd get a Bush type maybe. Or a Jade Goody. Neither would be ideal.

One of these days, a decent smart sensible monarch will come along (William?) who'll make a hell of a good job of it and all you revolutionaries will go quiet for another century. ;)

U-Know! Forum Index